The Bears were sure they had something special defensively in 2018.
With that side of the ball stacked, then further boosted by the trade for Khalil Mack going into the season, they were title-ready. All they needed was a decent offense.
That never came together, and the team wasted two seasons of elite defense as the other side of the ball wandered with coach Matt Nagy and quarterback Mitch Trubisky.
It was the opposite at Halas Hall this summer. The offense — including the trajectory of quarterback Caleb Williams — pointed upward under coach Ben Johnson, and the Bears hoped their defense could play well enough to get by.
The offense, indeed, has been one of the best in the league. And if the defense gets there, too, making a Super Bowl run would be very realistic.
The Bears had that in mind when they traded two first-round picks for star defensive tackle Jeffery Simmons last month. It was time to bring everything up to code and go for it.
As they head into their home game Sunday against the Saints, they aren’t there yet. The defense has gotten better since Week 1, when it allowed 37 points to the Panthers, but it still has work to do in key areas. It has been inconsistent against the run, and the best quarterbacks the Bears have faced have picked it apart (though that has improved since Simmons’ arrival).
The checklist for a championship-level defense starts with being tough to run against and tight in pass coverage, the latter of which also requiring a forceful pass rush. The Bears rank in the bottom half of the NFL in opponent passer rating (93.1) and yards per carry allowed (4.4).
Defensive tackle Grady Jarrett is fixated on that 4.4 number. It needs to be lower than four and ideally lower than 3.5.
One play can make all the difference in a game. The Bears would have held the Buccaneers to 3.7 yards per carry Nov. 8 had Bucky Irving’s 25-yard run in the fourth quarter not spiked it to 4.5. Nobody got to the gap on the left side, then Irving broke three tackles.
‘‘We’ve got to eliminate those things,’’ Jarrett said. ‘‘These one-off plays are throwing off our average.’’
Then there are the game-defining situations, such as third downs and trips to the red zone.
The Bears have been the best third-down defense in the league, holding opponents to a 22.8% conversion rate. The NFL record, according to Pro Football Reference, belongs to the 2019 Patriots at 24.1%.
In the red zone, the Bears have allowed touchdowns 53.8% of the time. That ranks 12th in the league.
It’s also essential to have a brilliant strategist running the defense, and Bears coordinator Dennis Allen has the résumé to claim that. Not only is he one of the most experienced defensive play-callers in the NFL, but he showed some savvy problem-solving skills in his first season and a half — before the Simmons trade — that the Bears lacked under Matt Eberflus, who ran the defense before him.
Those pieces are the foundation of a good defense, but it takes more to be great: blue-chip playmakers capable of taking over a game. The Bears have Simmons and nickel cornerback Kyler Gordon, but they need more than that.
They’re betting defensive end Montez Sweat rises to that level playing alongside Simmons, who draws double-teams and is constantly in his ear. And they hope safety Coby Bryant, who suffered a major knee injury in training camp, returns down the stretch or in the playoffs.
The Bears’ ultimate goal is to have a defense that can carry them in any given week if the offense sputters. It did against the Bucs, as Williams threw four interceptions and the ground game stalled, but that was against a bad team. The defense will be tested much more strenuously, with five of the Bears’ final seven games against teams in the top half of the league in total offense.
If the defense is as good as the Bears think, that’s a perfect ramp-up to the playoffs.